UK & CANADA NATIONAL HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL 2017
COLLABORATION WITH RON ARAD & DAVID ADJAYE
UK
NATIONAL HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL 2017
COLLABORATION WITH RON ARAD & DAVID ADJAYE
Victoria
Tower Gardens, London
The
winning competition entry, announced 24th October 2017, is the result of a
close process of collaboration between Ron Arad Architects, Adjaye Associates
and Gustafson, Porter + Bowman as Landscape Architects.
The
National Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre honour victims and survivors of
events now reaching the edge of living memory. It evokes shared experiences
which defy abstraction or simplification, but must also be inclusive, relevant
and resonant with a broader and younger audience.
A
gently meandering path leads across a gradually rising hill, inviting ascending
visitors for views of the river and Westminster. It is then revealed as a cliff
edge over a fractured landscape, held up by tall patinated bronze walls which
inscribe 22 paths - one for each country in which Jewish communities were
decimated during the Holocaust. Both cohesive and fragmented, the paths are a
shared experience only from afar; the journey through them is experienced individually,
as visitors are led down into the threshold below - a space for contemplation
and transition.
The
visceral, non-verbal experience, in close proximity to the bastion of
democracy, may inspire future generations to connect the events of the Holocaust
to other human tragedies of other times and places, and take a stance on wider
issues of human rights and freedoms.
YIDDISH WALL NEWSPAPER
GUSTAV KLIMT (1862-1918)
ADELE BLOCH – BAUER I, 1907 ( DETAIL)
GUSTAV KLIMT (1862-1918)
ADELE BLOCH – BAUER I, 1907
Oil, Silver, and Gold on Canvas
© 2015. Neue Galerie New York/Art Resource/Scala,
Florence
UK HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL
DESIGN BY RON ARAD & DAVID ADJAYE
Adjaye Associates, Ron Arad Architects and the
landscape architects Gustafson Porter + Bowman have been selected to design the
UK’s new Holocaust Memorial and Learning Centre.
After an international competition, with 92 entries in
total and ten finalists, Adjaye Associates, Ron Arad Architects and Gustafson
Porter + Bowman were selected unanimously as the winning team, by a jury
including the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, the
Mayor of London, the Chief Rabbi, experts from architecture, art and design,
and both first and second generation Holocaust survivors.
The design team will be led by British architect, Sir
David Adjaye, who is known for creating sensitive yet compelling designs. His
recent work includes the National Museum of African American History and
Culture in Washington D.C. and the Idea Stores in London’s Tower Hamlets.
Located next to the Houses of Parliament in
Westminster.
---------------------------------------------
Its co-located Learning Centre will contextualise the
memorial above and use the stories and facts of the Holocaust to explore
anti-Semitism, extremism, ......, racism, homophobia and other forms of
hatred and prejudice in society today. From its location next to Parliament, it
will ask questions about the role of society and its institutions in
encouraging respect for others and preventing hatred.
The jury praised the winning team’s proposal to create
“a living place, not just a monument to something of the past” and the desire
to create an immersive journey for the visitor who would enter a memorial
embedded in the land. The jury found the proposal deftly resolved an essential
challenge of the brief: being visually arresting (“highly visible from near and
far”) yet showing sensitivity to its location and context. The concept was
found to have clear potential to be developed into an iconic memorial and
intriguing educational experience, attracting visitors from the UK and beyond
to learn and reflect.
The winning concept is at an early design stage. It
will now undergo further development through discussion with Holocaust experts,
survivors and other victim groups, and local residents, Westminster City
Council, Historic England, Royal Parks and other statutory consultees. As part
of this process, the United Kingdom Holocaust Memorial Foundation will also
work closely with other organisations and experts on the contents and approach
of the co-located Learning Centre.
The jury also awarded honourable mentions to two teams
– heneghan peng architects and Sven Anderson, and Diamond Schmitt Architects.
DESCRIPTION OF THE WINNING CONCEPT
The winning design concept was inspired by research
into the site, Victoria Tower Gardens, next to the Houses of Parliament, with
Sir David Adjaye describing the location as a “park of Britain’s conscience”.
The memorial links with the statue of Emmeline Pankhurst, the Burghers of
Calais and the Buxton Memorial: all four recognising injustice and the need to
oppose it.
In order to keep the park as a park and to maintain
the green space, the team placed its Holocaust Memorial at the far southern end
of the gardens, embedded in the land. Accordingly, a visitor approaching the
memorial would see a subtle grass landform with only the tips of the memorial’s
fins “bristling in the distance”, its intriguing design giving a sense that
something is happening underground and encouraging people to find out more.
The design concept takes visitors on a journey that
culminates in confronting the 23 tall bronze fins of the memorial, the spaces
in between representing the 22 countries in which Jewish communities were
destroyed during the Holocaust. Entering the memorial would be a sensory
experience. While the outside and inside space emphasises collective gathering,
the 23 bronze fins require the visitor to enter in an isolated, solitary way,
each pathway planned as a different experience. Each path eventually leads down
into the Threshold – a generous hall which acts as a place of contemplation and
transition into the Learning Centre below ground. The Learning Centre includes
a “hall of testimonies” and a “Contemplation Court”: a silent, reflective space
with eight bronze panels. On leaving the memorial, the circulation route
ensures visitors will emerge to see the classic uninterrupted view of
Parliament – and the reality of democracy.
Sir David Adjaye, speaking on behalf of Adjaye
Associates, Ron Arad and Gustafson Porter + Bowman said:
The complexity of the Holocaust story, including the
British context, is a series of layers that have become hidden by time. Our
approach to the project has been to reveal these layers and not let them remain
buried under history. To do so, we wanted to create a living place, not just a
monument to something of the past. We wanted to orchestrate an experience that
reminds us of the fragility and constant strife for a more equitable world.
We are deeply honoured to have been given the
opportunity to tell these stories to the nation through a National Memorial and
Learning Centre. It is critical these highly important and emotive historical
touchpoints are explored, so that future generations are able to experience,
learn, reflect and act.
Secretary of State for Communities
and Local Government and jury member, Sajid Javid, said:
‘’Through this project, we stand up
as a nation; we stand together regardless of our religion, race or background;
and we stand against ignorance and bigotry. The new Learning Centre will not
only remind us of mankind’s capacity for darkness, through the story of the
Holocaust and other genocides - crucially, it will also remind us of our
incredible capacity for good.’’
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/adjaye-associates-and-ron-arad-architexts-win-uk-holocaust-memorial-international-design-competition
Milhomeh un Sholem, a Yiddish Translation of War and Peace
(Leo Tolstoy)
by Shelomoh Sheynberg. Vilna, 1927
ALBERT EINSTEIN 1921 PHOTO BY F. SCHMUTZER
'' The Prints and Etchings Room of the Felix Warburg Family Mansion, Built in 1908
and Donated to the Jewish Museum in 1944. Now ➡️ The Jewish Museum Ground Floor ''
Föhrenwald DP Camp Poster. Concert of Violinist
Patricia Travers Koncert - Fidlerin
Patricia Travers. American Jewish Joint
Distribution Committee AJDC, 1948, Undated
SALADOR DALI 1904 - 1989
SWANS REFLECTING ELEPHANTS 1937
Oil on Canvas
Dimensions: 51 x 77 cm
Private Collection
'' A Rare 16th Century Hebrew Book Was Among the First Books to be
In the Oldest Synagogue in the City,
the Synagogue of Saul ben Judah Wahl (1541-ca.1617, Who Was King of Poland for
24 hours,) an Old Man Sits Over a Book on the Wooden Steps Leading to the
'Bimah' ( Reader's Platform ), Lublin, pre-1924.
Yivo Reading Room, Man Reads Yiddish Paper
“A tyrannical ship captain inveigled Jewish children aboard
his ship and their mothers gathered on the shore to save their children.” This
image is from the 1901 Yiddish translation of Solomon ibn Verga’s classic
Hebrew work Shevet Yehudah (The Staff of Judah), first printed in Turkey in the
mid-16th century. The book chronicles persecutions of Jews in different lands,
especially in Spain. This book from the YIVO Library is one of the many Yiddish
books now being digitized for YIVO’s Vilna Collections project. It was once
part of the famed Strashun Jewish public library in Vilna. ''
EGON SCHIELE
WOMAN HIDING HER FACE 1912
Collector Fritz Grunbaum
A Vivo Library & Archives Stamp New York Ca. 1940
NATIONAL HOLOCAUST MONUMENT OTTAWA, CANADA 2014
RON ARAD & DAVID ADJAYE
NATIONAL
HOLOCAUST MONUMENT OTTAWA, CANADA 2014
RON
ARAD & DAVID ADJAYE
A
design collaboration between Ron Arad Architects and David Adjaye
Associates, with Art Strategies Inc & Tatar Art Projects.
Addressing
the challenge and responsibility of creating a public monument which evokes a
shared set of experiences relating to the holocaust and its survivors
-experiences which defy abstraction or simplification- is fundamental to our
proposal. It must also honour the victims and survivors of events which took
place a great distance away from Canadian soil, and which are now reaching the
edge of living memory.
Shunning
direct didactic or symbolic content, our proposal centres on an array of thin
walls or foils, 14m in height and 20m in length, spaced 120cm apart from each
other -just enough for a visitor to pass through in single file. Passage
through the monument is a shared experience only from a distance, and in
retrospect, once others have journeyed through it as well.
There
are 23 textured, tinted and articulated concrete foils in total, facilitating
22 pathways -one for each country in which Jewish communities were decimated
during the Holocaust. Their combined impact, an interplay between robustness
and frailty, cohesiveness and fragmentation. The narrow passages pull the eye
upwards, through canyon-like undulations which frame the sky above.
http://www.ronarad.co.uk/architecture/national-holocaust-monument-ottawa/
Part of the Strashun Library collection, this book is an
example of a sefer evronot,
a genre that uses rabbinic chronology for
determining how to calculate
the Jewish calendar and times for prayer.
'' People receiving packages, at the
remittance office of the American Jewish
Joint Distribution Committee,
Warszawa, 1920 ''
CANADA’S
NATIONAL HOLOCAUST MONUMENT DESIGN BY
DAVID
ADJAYE & RON ARAD
Here's
the design that didn't win: architect David Adjaye and designer Ron
Arad have revealed their shortlisted entry for Canada's
National Holocaust Monument competition.
David Adjaye and Ron Arad teamed up with art historian
and curator Irene Szylinger and public arts consultant Tatar Art Projects on their proposal
for the memorial, planned for a site in the Canadian capital, Ottawa.
The
designers describe these as "at times almost perfectly smooth to the
touch, and at others left punctuated by the variation of stone aggregate within
them".
Here's
a project description from the designers:
National
Holocaust Monument Ottawa
" The
enormous historical literary and dramatic material produced over nearly half a
century about the Final Solution, has created a kind of resistance. But it
would be perilous if we allowed this "compassion fatigue" to make us
forget the singularity of this horror" – Gitta Sereny, 1996
When
faced with the daunting task of formulating a design brief for a memorial to
honour the victims and survivors of that most recognised of collective human
travesties, one cannot escape a fundamental conundrum. How can a monument in
the public realm evoke a shared set of experiences relating to the Holocaust
and its survivors – experiences which defy abstraction or simplification, by
virtue of their being so specific, so traumatic and personal?
Furthermore,
the Holocaust Memorial is a Canadian monument honouring the victims and
survivors of events which took place a great distance away from Canadian soil,
and which are now reaching the edge of living memory.
There
is thus an implied responsibility to both strongly anchor the memorial in
Canada, home to the fourth largest Jewish population in the world, and to make
it inclusive, relevant and strongly resonant with any who visit it, and
especially a younger and broader audience. We have been given the opportunity,
and have the freedom to build the memorial which stands as evidence for future
generations, and the very introduction of such a monument to the capital of
this model democracy, defies forgetfulness, or worse, the denial of the
Holocaust.
The
monument centres on an array of thin walls or foils, each up to 14m in height
and 20m in length, spaced 120 centimetres apart from each other – just enough
for a visitor to pass through in single passage. While we resist prescribing an
'experience' or enforcing didactic content onto the memorial, our proposal does
pose a central, unavoidable theme – the voyage the visitor makes through these
foils is one each must take alone. It is a shared experience only from a
distance, and in retrospect, once others have journeyed through it as well.
The
higher reaches of these foils are individually articulated through dramatic
folds and impressions to create an undulating, and at times frayed appearance.
These are redolent of the imprints, or scars which events may leave in their
wake – the tracery of damage which is both testament to history, and a mark
carried into the future.
There
are 23 concrete foils in total, facilitating 22 pathways – one for each country
in which Jewish communities were decimated during the Holocaust. Their combined
impact is an interplay between robustness and frailty, cohesiveness and
fragmentation; like pages in a book, or individual members in a tightknit
community.
The
foils are to be built as slim (it is envisaged that they would range between
50cm at their widest, to approximately 15cm at their thinnest edge),
steel-reinforced concrete elements, formed in such a way as to celebrate a wide
spectrum of textures; at times almost perfectly smooth to the touch, and at
others left punctuated by the variation of stone aggregate within them. The
narrow, linear passage between these cannot but pull the eyes upwards, to
reveal the canyon-like undulations which frame the sky above. These vary from
passage to passage, and may provoke and evoke a variety of emotions and connotations,
such as the naturally occurring ravines in the Jordanian desert, or the charged
tunnels beneath Jerusalem's ancient Western Wall.
As
darkness falls, floor-mounted uplighters near both edges of each foil serve to
accentuate the thin sculptural outer faces of each one. From afar, the cohesive
volume which envelopes the monument is delicately broken down into its almost
frail-looking component parts. From within, and still accessible, the monument
offers a well-lit environment from which to enter each pathway. These lead into
the darker centre of the path, and ultimately into the light at the end of each
passage.
We
believe and hope that the immediacy of the physical, non-verbal experience
offered by the monument, beyond its categorisation as architectural or
sculptural, will serve to inspire future generations to connect the events of
the Holocaust to other human tragedies of other times and places, and take a
stance on wider issues of human rights and freedoms.
https://www.dezeen.com/2014/05/19/david-adjaye-ron-arad-national-holocaust-monument-entry/
EDWARD MUNCH 1863 - 1944
SCREAM 1893
Dimensions: 91 cm × 73.5 cm (36 in × 28.9 in)
National Gallery, Oslo, Norway
DAVID ADJAYE – APPROACH
ARCHITECTURE
Adjaye
Associates believes that architecture presents opportunities for transformation
– materially, conceptually and sociologically. Driven by the desire to enrich
and improve daily life, the practice’s buildings are designed to meet the
diverse needs of the communities they serve. Inspiration is drawn from many
influences around the world and the work clearly articulates this enthusiasm
for issues of place and identity.
The
buildings belong to yet diverge from their contexts, absorbing and animating
difference rather than homogenising it. They are bold statements of a complex
contemporary world and an unsettled territory of cultural
experimentation. Private residences are places of urban retreat, while the
civic buildings dissolve the idea of the institution. The emphasis on
light, a distinctive material and colour palette, the play between
positive and negative and the ability to turn constraints into compelling
narratives, are critical themes.
PLANNING
& URBANISM
David
Adjaye’s vision is one that promotes multiple interpretations of the civic
experience. The approach to urban development is driven by the
human-scaled complexities of urban living in parallel with the driving
forces of topography, geography and climate. The celebration of difference that
lies at the heart of the practice’s architecture feeds into its master
planning projects – whether school and university campuses, re-developed
urban quarters or entirely new cities. The work avoids monolithic
statements and the use of utility logics to organise urban
frameworks. Rather, it is dominated by the experience of transition, the
possibility for capturing memory and meaning and the constant striving for
an organic quality that can shift to express the sense of the city as
a constantly evolving organism. Adjaye’s ability to navigate many forms of
knowledge – from science, engineering and environment to artistic intervention
or community involvement – is key to the master planning methodology.
PRODUCTS
Adjaye
Associates works at many different scales, with products and furniture
providing a testing ground for form as well as materials. This is something
that powerfully informs the wider body of work – from residential to large
civic projects. A number of these larger projects benefit from a complete
service - from architecture and planning down to the smallest details such as
the furniture and signage, while some residential projects encompass
permanent furniture elements that are integrated into the overall structure.
COLLABORATION
COLLABORATION
David
Adjaye’s belief in working together with artists and other cultural thinkers
has led to a number of notable collaborations and a lively cultural and
creative discourse surrounding his practice. Adjaye Associates established its
early reputation with a series of private houses where the artist was
client, and this dialogue continues with recent public buildings,
pavilions and exhibitions.
“ I like
to collaborate with artists that see space and structure as integral to
their work. It involves a merging
of skills and aesthetics to create something that has more potential than
either discipline can achieve on its own. ” (David Adjaye)
RESEARCH
David
Adjaye is widely seen as a role model for future generations. He participates
in exhibitions, lectures, symposia, publishing projects and television. The
research arm of the practice is vital to the creative discourse that drives its
built work. While every individual project has unique qualities, it is the
practice’s research that provides an overarching framework for
experimentation, reflection and theoretical connections. This
philosophical curve is an essential context for challenging typologies, engaging with
historical references and offering a fresh approach to the contemporary
condition and its future trajectories.
SUSTAINABILITY
“ Sustainability
is not just material use or energy use... it is lifestyle. ‘’ (David Adjaye)
The
idea of the material of sustainability is something Adjaye Associates believes
that we have to move away from. Sustainability is about the whole philosophy of
how you use and live. It is therefore not an add-on or even something that we
consciously separate out from the design concept. The practice
continually experiments with recycled, inexpensive materials and seeks to
achieve the optimum environment through orientation, shading and sensitivity to
the local climate.
There
are very few locations in which people can live continuously without modifying
the climatic conditions to maintain their comfort, and with global warming this
is likely to become more necessary.
On the other hand, climatic conditions often determine aspects of a place that we most appreciate.
Adjaye Associates has developed a language of form that makes it possible to enjoy the specifics of climate while, at the same time, making modifications to the climate on a largely passive basis. The form of the Moscow School of Management, for example, was largely dictated by the need to deal with an extreme winter. The disc became a solution to misimise campus sprawl so that the entire campus is a compact and therefore more energy efficient mass.
On the other hand, climatic conditions often determine aspects of a place that we most appreciate.
Adjaye Associates has developed a language of form that makes it possible to enjoy the specifics of climate while, at the same time, making modifications to the climate on a largely passive basis. The form of the Moscow School of Management, for example, was largely dictated by the need to deal with an extreme winter. The disc became a solution to misimise campus sprawl so that the entire campus is a compact and therefore more energy efficient mass.
A
number of buildings have achieved the relevant environmental accreditation –
for example the Denver Art Museum was awarded LEED gold. Similarly, the
practice has been very ambitious with the environmental strategy for the
National Museum of African American History and Culture, which will achieve a
minimum of a LEED Gold rating, while the recently opened Francis Gregory
Library in Washington DC has achieved LEED silver and its partner library, the
William O. Lockridge Bellevue Library surpassed the projected LEED silver
to achieve LEED Gold.
DAVID
ADJAYE – PRINCIPAL
KEY
DATA & BIOGRAPHY
Sir
David Adjaye OBE is recognized as a leading architect of his generation. Adjaye
was born in Tanzania to Ghanaian parents and his influences range from
contemporary art, music and science to African art forms and the civic life of
cities. In 1994, he set up his first office, where his ingenious use of
materials and his sculptural ability established him as an architect with an artist’s
sensibility and vision. He reformed his studio as Adjaye Associates in 2000.
The firm now has offices in London, New York and Accra with projects in the US,
UK, Europe, Africa, Asia and the Middle East. His largest project to date, the
$540 million Smithsonian Institute National Museum of African American History
and Culture, opened on the National Mall in Washington DC in fall of 2016 and
was named Cultural Event of the Year by the New York Times.
Other
prominent completed work include the Idea Stores in London (2005), which were
credited with pioneering a new approach to library services, the Moscow School
of Management SKOLKOVO (2010), the Sugar Hill mixed-use social housing scheme
in Harlem, New York (2015); and the Aishti Foundation retail and art complex in
Beirut (2015). Prominent ongoing projects include a new home for the Studio
Museum in Harlem, New York, a new headquarters building for the International
Finance Corporation in Dakar, and the just-announced National Holocaust
Memorial and Learning Centre in London.
In
2017, Adjaye was recently knighted by Her Majesty the Queen for services to
Architecture, following the previous award of an OBE in 2007. The same year, he
was recognized as one of the 100 most influential people of the year by TIME
magazine. He has additionally received the Design Miami/ Artist of the Year
title in 2011, the Wall Street Journal Innovator Award in 2013 and the 2016
Panerai London Design Medal from the London Design Festival.
Adjaye
is known for his frequent collaborations with contemporary artists on
installations and exhibitions. Most notably, he designed the 56th Venice Art
Biennale with curator Okwui Enwezor (2015). The Upper Room, featuring thirteen
paintings by Chris Ofili (2002), is now part of the permanent collection of
Tate Britain. Further examples include Within Reach, a second installation with
Ofili in the British pavilion at the Venice Biennale (2003) and the
Thyssen-Bornemisza Art for the 21st Century Pavilion that was designed to show
Your Black Horizon, a projection work by Olafur Eliasson, at the 2005 Venice
Biennale.
Adjaye
has held distinguished professorships at the Harvard, Princeton and Yale
universities. He has also taught at the Royal College of Art, where he had
previously studied, and at the Architectural Association School in London. The
material from his ten-year study of the capital cities of Africa was exhibited
as Urban Africa at London’s Design Museum (2010) and published as Adjaye Africa
Architecture (Thames & Hudson, 2011). He was the artistic director of
GEO-graphics: A map of art practices in Africa, past and present, a major
exhibition at the Centre for Fine Arts, Brussels (2010). In 2015, a
comprehensive retrospective exhibition of his work to date launched at Haus der
Kunst in Munich and the Art Institute of Chicago, and was subsequently shown at
the Garage Museum of Contemporary Art in Moscow.
http://www.adjaye.com/about/team/david-adjaye/
RON ARAD
Born in
Tel Aviv in 1951, educated at the Jerusalem Academy of Art and later at the
Architectural Association in London, Ron Arad co-founded with Caroline Thorman
the design and production studio One Off in 1981 and later, in 1989, Ron Arad
Associates architecture and design practice. In 2008 Ron Arad Architects was
established alongside Ron Arad Associates.
From
1994 to 1999 he established the Ron Arad Studio, design and production unit in
Como, Italy. He was Professor of Design Product at the Royal College of Art in
London up until 2009. Ron Arad was awarded the 2011 London Design Week Medal
for design excellence and was became a Royal Academician of the Royal Academy
of Arts in 2013.
Ron
Arad’s constant experimentation with the possibilities of materials such as
steel, aluminium or polyamide and his radical re-conception of the form and
structure of furniture has put him at the forefront of contemporary design and
architecture.
Alongside
his limited edition studio work, Arad designs for many leading international
companies including Kartell, Vitra, Moroso, Fiam, Driade, Alessi, Cappellini,
Cassina, WMF and Magis among many others.
Ron
Arad has designed a number of Public Art pieces, most recently the Vortext in
Seoul, Korea, and the Kesher Sculpture at Tel Aviv University.
http://www.ronarad.co.uk/press/biography/